Common Challenges in Education in North Rhine-Westphalia and Pennsylvania
In March 2026, we traveled to North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) Germany as part of the PSBA Institute’s International Education Study Group. Although we had never met in person before this trip, we quickly connected through our experiences in school board leadership, our districts and the realities of leading public education today. It also became immediately clear that despite our geographic proximity, we each navigate a mix of shared pressures and distinct local challenges within our districts.
That theme – common ground within different contexts – only deepened once we arrived in Germany. While Germany is geographically far from where we live, our experience on the trip quickly revealed meaningful parallels. The challenges we often think of as uniquely Pennsylvanian or American, are, in fact, global.
A Systemic Challenge: Teacher Shortages
Through our many conversations and discussions with educators, university leaders, and government officials, one issue surfaced repeatedly: staffing the teaching profession. Despite differences in governance structures, funding frameworks and educational systems, both Germany and the United States are grappling with several similar systemic challenges – fewer people are entering, and staying in, the field of education.
This is not anecdotal. In fact, according to a report released by UNESCO and the International Taskforce on Teachers for Education, the world is projected to face a shortage of 44 million teachers by 2030. What both countries are experiencing is part of a much broader, global trend.
Teacher Shortages in Pennsylvania
In Pennsylvania, the causes of teacher shortages are multifaceted and include declining enrollment in teacher preparation programs, increased attrition, and the growing and intensified demands on educators.
For school boards and district leaders, these trends are not abstract. School districts are faced with difficult decisions about course offerings, class sizes and staffing models. In many cases, these operational realities force difficult tradeoffs that directly impact students, educators and the overall quality of public education.
At the same time, even in districts across Pennsylvania that pride themselves on offering a robust and varied high school curriculum, gaps persist. As such, we often face challenges when trying to fulfill specific types of teacher roles, particularly in special education, chemistry and foreign languages. However, these are not isolated challenges; rather, they are structural ones.
Solutions to Teacher Shortages in NRW
Throughout our time in NRW, we had several opportunities to discuss how Germany is approaching these same challenges, including visits to the Ministry of Education and the University of Wuppertal. What stood out was not just the policies themselves, but the clarity with which teacher shortages are treated as a systemwide issue requiring both consistency and — sometimes — flexible, short-term solutions.
Policy in Action
At the Ministry of Education of NRW, we learned the state has taken a pragmatic approach. In response to the strain on traditional teacher preparation pipelines, NRW has expanded hiring pathways beyond traditionally trained educators, allowing individuals with subject-matter expertise (such as lawyers teaching law-related courses) to enter classrooms without completing full teacher certification.
In practice, this is similar to what we often see in the United States with guest lecturers in colleges. Currently, approximately 12.8% of new hires in NRW come through these alternative routes. While these urgent solutions outside traditional systems help prevent canceled lessons and ensure continuity for students, they also underscore the strain on the pipeline to produce fully qualified teachers.
To further improve recruitment, NRW has implemented steps to strengthen recruitment by equalizing teacher salaries across regions and school types, reducing disparities that might otherwise deter candidates.
Educational Training
At the University of Wuppertal School of Education, we saw how these policies translate into practice and teacher preparation is guided by state-level policy decisions. With more than 20,000 students enrolled across nine schools focused on education, the program reflects a highly coordinated, state-aligned approach to teacher pipeline development in NRW.
Candidates progress through a six-semester bachelor’s degree, followed by a two-semester master’s program, and a one-and-a-half-year traineeship. One of the program’s most impactful features occurs at the very beginning of their studies: teacher candidates must select their intended teaching track (primary, special, secondary, high school, vocational or bilingual) in alignment with state needs.
To address shortages, particularly in critical subject areas, NRW implemented a dual-certification requirement at the primary level. This mandate requires that all teacher candidates, regardless of their initial focus, study both mathematics and German. By requiring competency in multiple core subjects, this approach expands staffing flexibility for schools. It reduces dependency on hard-to-fill, single-subject roles by ensuring all graduates are prepared to meet essential instructional needs, ultimately strengthening the overall teacher workforce.
Global Challenge, Global Solutions
As local governing bodies, school boards play a critical role in advocating for policies that balance flexibility with instructional quality. Addressing teacher shortages requires a balance between immediate, practical solutions and long-term, systemic planning. It requires flexibility, but not at the expense of instructional quality.
The question is no longer whether teacher shortages will continue, but how we choose to respond. For those of us serving on school boards, we are uniquely positioned to advocate for policies that strengthen the educator pipeline while maintaining high standards for teaching and learning.
In Pennsylvania, recent changes to teacher certification under Act 47 of 2025 have already begun to reshape the landscape by broadening certification grade bands to primary (PreK–6) and secondary (7–12). These adjustments allow for greater staffing flexibility, enabling educators to teach across a wider range of grade levels (such as PreK–4 teachers now being permitted to teach grades 5–6).
The example of NRW provides a case study in how structural alignment between teacher preparation and workforce needs can yield measurable benefits. While differences in governance and policy limit direct replication, the underlying principle remains highly applicable — intentional design of certification pathways and workforce needs results in a more resilient and adaptable educator pipeline.
Bridging the Skills Gap: Expanding Access to Technical Careers Through Business-Supported Apprenticeships — a North Rhine-Westphalia Solution
Across the United States, a quiet but significant workforce challenge is growing: the gap between available skilled technical jobs and the number of trained workers ready to fill them. Skilled technical careers — those requiring specialized knowledge without a four-year college degree — are essential to the nation’s infrastructure, manufacturing, health care and energy sectors. Yet access to training pathways into these careers remains uneven, fragmented and often misunderstood.
The data underscores the urgency. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projects growth in skilled trades ranging from 4% to as high as 60% through 2033, depending on the occupation. Meanwhile, a recent economic impact report by Bring Back the Trades, Inc., conducted with F.W. Webb Company, estimates that nearly 1.4 million trade jobs could go unfilled nationwide by 2030. This mismatch between supply and demand is not due to a lack of opportunity but rather a lack of structured, accessible pathways for students to enter these fields.
The Access Problem in the U.S.
In Pennsylvania and across much of the country, apprenticeship opportunities do exist. The Apprenticeship and Training Office within the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry supports programs statewide. However, these efforts are largely decentralized, varying significantly by region, industry and employer participation. Without a cohesive system, students often face barriers in discovering, accessing and committing to technical career pathways.
Additionally, cultural perceptions play a role. Four-year college degrees continue to dominate the narrative of postsecondary success, leaving vocational and technical careers undervalued despite their strong earning potential and job security. This disconnect contributes to both student uncertainty and employer frustration.
A Proven Model: Germany’s Dual VET System
In contrast, Germany offers a compelling example of how to align education, industry and workforce development through its dual vocational education and training (VET) system. This nationally coordinated model integrates classroom instruction at vocational schools with hands-on training at participating companies.
Germany currently offers over 320 recognized training occupations, with programs typically lasting between two and three-and-a-half years. Apprentices are paid employees from the start, gaining real-world experience while earning a salary. The results are striking: vocational training programs in Germany achieve a 92% job placement rate and contribute significantly to the country’s low youth unemployment.
The success of the dual VET system is rooted in several key factors:
- Strong societal acceptance of vocational education as a respected career path
- Close alignment between training programs and employer needs
- Active involvement of chambers of commerce and industry groups
- A clear, standardized structure that ensures quality and consistency nationwide
Participation in the system is formalized through employment contracts between students and companies, reinforcing the seriousness and mutual commitment of the apprenticeship experience.
Lessons from North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW)
Vocational education plays a particularly vital role in North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW), Germany’s most populous state and a major industrial hub. During a recent delegation visit, participants observed firsthand how the dual VET system operates in practice.
At the Bayer AG Research and Development Center in Wuppertal-Aprath, apprentices train in advanced laboratory environments as part of three-year programs. Currently, 152 apprentices across eight occupational fields are engaged in training that combines on-site practical experience with theoretical instruction at vocational schools, known as Berufsschulen.
These programs are not abstract or exploratory — they are directly tied to workforce needs. Apprentices preparing to become biology or chemical laboratory technicians work with the same equipment and processes used by full-time employees. Conversations with apprentices revealed a clear sense of purpose: they understood their career paths, had secured employment and were actively building skills aligned with their future roles.
Another critical component of the system is the role of chambers of commerce, such as the Chamber of Industry and Commerce Rheinhessen (IHK). These organizations serve as the “competent authority” overseeing apprenticeship programs. They ensure quality by certifying companies and instructors, registering apprenticeship contracts, administering examinations, and issuing nationally recognized credentials. This centralized oversight provides consistency and trust across industries.
The Role of Employers: Investment and Return
A defining feature of Germany’s model is the level of employer investment. Companies pay apprentices monthly salaries and often cover the costs associated with training. Many large firms, like Bayer, operate dedicated in-house training centers, allowing them to tailor programs to their specific workforce needs.
While this level of investment may seem significant, the return is equally substantial. Because apprentices are trained within the company environment, they are more likely to transition seamlessly into full-time roles. This reduces recruitment costs, shortens onboarding periods, and increases employee retention and loyalty.
In essence, apprenticeship programs function as long-term talent pipelines rather than short-term expenses.
A Path Forward for the U.S.
Adapting elements of the dual VET system to the U.S., and to states like Pennsylvania, does not require a complete overhaul of existing structures. Instead, it calls for stronger coordination, increased employer engagement, and a shift in how technical careers are perceived and promoted.
Key opportunities include:
- Expanding partnerships between employers, schools, and workforce agencies
- Encouraging businesses to invest in structured apprenticeship programs
- Improving awareness among students, parents and educators about technical career pathways
- Developing more standardized frameworks to ensure program quality and portability
Perhaps most importantly, stakeholders must clearly communicate the return on investment for businesses. Apprenticeships are not merely workforce development tools — they are strategic investments that yield measurable economic benefits.
Conclusion
The challenge of student access to technical skill development is not insurmountable. Models like Germany’s dual VET system demonstrate that when education and industry work in tandem, the results can be transformative for both individuals and economies.
For the U.S., the path forward lies in embracing business-supported apprenticeships as a central component of workforce strategy. By aligning training with real-world needs, investing in students as future employees and elevating the value of skilled technical careers, we can begin to close the skills gap and unlock opportunity for the next generation.
Group Participants
- Jill Martin, Board President, Palmyra Area School District
- Allison Mathis, Board President, North Hills School District
- Antonio Paris, Board President, Riverview School District
- Ashley Turner, School Director, York Suburban School District